The American College of Radiology (ACR) urges members to take a course on systemic racism and white privilege, sparking controversy over its emphasis on critical race theory in healthcare.
A Move Aimed At Promoting Diversity
In a move aimed at promoting diversity, equity, and inclusion within the medical community, a professional medical society representing thousands of doctors and scientists in the radiology specialty, the American College of Radiology (ACR), has strongly encouraged its members to participate in a course on systemic racism and white privilege.
Screenshots Reveal Course Content
Screenshots obtained by the American Accountability Foundation reveal the course’s content and objectives.
“Health Equity: Life in Black and White”
Titled “Health Equity: Life in Black and White,” the course targets doctors and medical students associated with the ACR, prompting them to delve into critical concepts such as microaggressions, tone policing, racial profiling, privilege, anti-racism, intersectionality, and unconscious or implicit bias.
They Watch Instructive Videos: “5 Tips for Being an Ally”
Participants are encouraged to engage in group settings, where they watch instructive videos, including the Ted Talk “Color Blind or Color Brave” and “5 Tips for Being an Ally.”
Additional Reading: “The Role of White Co-conspirators in Dismantling Systemic Racism”
Suggested reading materials encompass articles like “We Need Co-conspirators, Not Allies” and “The Role of White Co-conspirators in Dismantling Systemic Racism.”
“Identity and Privilege“ in a Flow Chart
Central to the course is a flow chart titled “Identity and Privilege,” categorizing identity groups according to their historical access to benefits and recognition.
People Ranked by Privilege
The chart ranks individuals with the most privilege as men and boys, white people, those aged 35-60, Christians, heterosexual and cis-gender individuals, those without disabilities, and people with possessions, humorously comparing them to looking like “Ken or Barbie.”
Identifying Groups With the Least Privilege
Conversely, the group with the least privilege includes women and girls, black people and people of color, young individuals and elders, LGBT individuals, the working class, and people with disabilities.
Oppression Based on Religious Beliefs
The course also acknowledges that people from various religious backgrounds face oppression, including Muslims, Jews, atheists, and others.
Recognizing Unconscious Bias
Another critical module in the course focuses on recognizing unconscious biases in the administration of healthcare.
Participants are presented with scenarios to test their awareness, prompting them to consider their reactions and judgment in various medical situations.
One Scenario in the Lesson
One such scenario involves Sara Ali, a devout Muslim, experiencing difficulties getting pregnant, and the participants are asked which imaging test they would order as part of her infertility workup.
Healthcare as a System of Power
The course addresses the issue of the healthcare system being a “system of power,” pointing out disparities in its treatment based on race, gender, sexual orientation, and other identities.
Equal Screening Rates for Breast Cancer
Participants are urged to contemplate how to ensure equal screening rates for breast cancer among women of color compared to white and Asian women and how to reduce the rate of delayed diagnosis and workup in women of color.
Not Everyone Is in Favor
While the ACR has taken steps to promote health equity, not everyone is in favor of this approach.
The Course Has Faced Opposition
Dr. Stanley Goldfarb, Chairman of Do No Harm, criticizes the course as a collection of clichés derived from critical race theory, asserting that it assumes white people, particularly white males, oppress others in society without empirical evidence to support such claims.
He advocates for a focus on rigorous medical training and manners rather than social theories.
In the Wake of George Floyd
The ACR, in response, stated that it is not conducting the course, highlighting that it is just one of many organizations that waded into social-justice programming and the politicization of medicine following the unrest triggered by the murder of George Floyd in 2020.
Aiming to Combat Health Disparities Based on Race
During the ACR’s annual meeting in 2021, the organization’s outgoing president announced the establishment of the Radiology Health Equity Coalition, aiming to combat health disparities based on race.
Collaborating Using Different Methods
The ACR pledged its commitment to advancing health equity through collaboration with coalition members, research, artificial intelligence development, and radiology trainee and medical student recruitment efforts.
Role of Critical Race Theory in Medicine
Although striving for health equity and fighting against racism are commendable objectives, the course has ignited a heated debate, prompting inquiries into critical race theory’s role in the medical field and its potential influence on healthcare decision-making.
Challenges of Addressing Disparities
As the medical community grapples with issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion, striking a balance between addressing disparities and preserving a merit-based approach remains a challenging yet crucial task.
Her Friend Said She Was Pathetic, so She Canceled a $12,000 Gift Payment for Her Fertility Treatments!
A frustrated woman recently took to Reddit to ask for opinions after she canceled a $12,000 payment to help her friend pay for fertility treatments. Her Friend Said She Was Pathetic, so She Canceled a $12,000 Gift Payment for Her Fertility Treatments!
He Secretly Throws a ‘Rare’ Steak Out the Window, Only to Realize It Is Closed, and It Catches the Attention of Everyone in the Restaurant!
In an attempt to get away with not eating a severely undercooked steak during dinner with his wife’s boss, this guy fails miserably. The resulting situation is far more embarrassing than he expected. He Secretly Throws a ‘Rare’ Steak Out the Window, Only to Realize It Is Closed, and It Catches the Attention of Everyone in the Restaurant!
Clever Woman ‘Sprinkler Showers’ Her Trespassing Neighbors Who Refused to Leave Her Yard
A woman was shocked to find the peacefulness of her own home disrupted by crazy strangers. When they refused to leave, she had to get creative. Read on to hear her full story! Clever Woman ‘Sprinkler Showers’ Her Trespassing Neighbors Who Refused to Leave Her Yard
His Mother and Sister Demanded That His Wife Should Stay at Home, He Would Only Allow It if They Agree to Pay Their House Bills!
A confused and frustrated husband sparked outrage on Reddit after he told his mom and sister to pay his bills if they thought his wife should give up her job. He feels bamboozled by the whole situation. Here is his full story. His Mother and Sister Demanded That His Wife Should Stay at Home, He Would Only Allow It if They Agree to Pay Their House Bills!
She Denied Her Future In-Laws Access to Her Son’s Wedding Fund, Which They Desired for Their Benefit!
This mother sought advice from the Reddit community after her son’s future in-laws asked her for the money she was going to use for the wedding – instead of paying for the wedding! She Denied Her Future In-Laws Access to Her Son’s Wedding Fund, Which They Desired for Their Benefit!
Featured Image Credit: Shutterstock / RHIMAGE. The people shown in the images are for illustrative purposes only, not the actual people featured in the story.